As we ponder and implement NEP 2020, the question of identity, culture, ethnicity, language, education and time-tested and research-based shreds of evidence formulates one aspect clear that teaching students in their mother tongue makes them much more comfortable and sharp than teaching them in any other language. however, UNESCO data confirms that around 40% of worldwide learners are educated in a language other than their mother tongue.
This leads
to numerous problems. Students face setbacks and other social and educational
hiccups. To address this issue, the government of India, through NEP 2020 took
the revolutionary decision of giving education in the mother tongue. So Central
Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) ordering to use the mother tongue for teaching
is a needed and admirable move.
Singapore,
Thailand, China, Israel, China, Taiwan, Japan etc got independence almost with
India. However, their education system is much better than the Indian education
system. One of the most important reasons for this high standard is teaching in
mother tongues.
Thomas
Macaulay loathed India and the Indian education system and created a new
English education system to produce a class to help the British govern and
control India and the Indians. This was Indian in colour and blood but British
in morals, opinions, taste and style. They were more British and less Indian.
That was the metamorphosis, the English language brought into the lives of
Indians.
Noticing
this fall, Gandhiji and some other nationalist leaders expressed their deep
distress over English education. Not only this, they realised that the English
language is creating a deep divide and inequality between English-educated and
non-English-educated people. This English has crippled the educated class mentally
prejudiced and wounded, morally clumsy and disconnected from their land,
society, culture and families. In other words, they are less patriotic and
ready to leave their motherland, kith and kin at the first opportunity.
Nationalist
leaders like Purshottam Das Tandon, C. Rajagopalachari, Govind Ballabh Pant,
Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Gopal Krishna Gokhale, Annie Besant, Shyama Prasad
Mukherjee, etc understood the negative impact of English on Indians. These
leaders and freedom fighters not only have a brilliant understanding of the
people and culture of India but also its fabulous spiritual and literary
heritage. They supported early education in Hindi or their tongue and English
as a second language.
Interestedly
leaders like Nehru, Ambedkar, Seth Govind Das, Abul Kalam Azad, T.T.
Krishnamachari, and E.V. Ramaswamy (Periyar), advocated English. Now, it is a
well-known fact that education in the mother tongue is highly beneficial for
children. UNESCO, through its Global Monitoring Education report, has supported
early education in the mother tongue. Mother tongue-based bilingual schooling
is much more useful than any other language for pedagogical grounds.
There is a
big delusion in India, that without good English, one cannot get a good job.
They are made to believe that education in the mother tongue deprives students
of a good career. However, researchers have different opinions. Students with
their mother tongue at the schooling medium found it very easy to master
English later. When students learn English or any other second language later
in their career, the skills learnt while being trained in their mother tongue
can be used.
Research at
the University of Ontario and on Latin American-origin learners found that
proficiency in English is directly related to the teachings of English at the
school level. The students who have early education in their mother tongue were
found better in English than those who have been introduced to English at the
school level.
In India,
school education has given birth to many educational and social problems.
Education in a language other than the mother tongue has dropped the literacy
rate by 18% to 20%. The college dropout rate is increased by 20% to 22%. It is
high time that policymakers must renounce the idea that English education is
essential for the career growth and progress of the nation.
English-educated
people in India are seen as very self-centred. Getting and chance, Convent
educated and English medium learners are always ready to leave their families
and the nation. They also found lacking in nationalism and family ties. Senior
citizens can be seen living alone and their children settled abroad. This is
the biggest reward of English medium education.
Apart from
benefits, education in the mother tongue is a fundamental right of every child.
Teachings in the mother tongue also lead to the upliftment of cultural,
spiritual and value systems. Such education can strengthen society and the
nation. So the NEP and CBSE policymakers should follow up on admissions,
teacher recruitment, curriculum expansion and development and teaching material
to cater for the need of Indian language students.
The Indian
Education system is hijacked by English Education. Those methods represented in
the past the value, culture and ethos are to be recaptured to enable students
to focus towards free-thinking, rational approach, nationalism culture and
value system. The nasty ghost of Maucauly went so deep into the psyche of
Indian Elites and the policymakers that they could not visualize that the soul
of their country has been mortgaged with the mortal and suicidal darkness.